
Air Polishing in Dental Cleaning: Is Every Treatment the Same?
In air polishing the difference lies not in the name of the device but in the powder, the sequence and guidance by disclosing.
Short answer: no, they are not the same
Air polishing, widely known as “airflow”, removes the bacterial layer and stains from the tooth surface with a mixture of pressurised air, water and a fine powder. It is now offered in many places.
But treatments carrying the same name can differ considerably. Three things make the difference: which powder is used, the order in which the procedure is done, and what guides the cleaning.
In this article I explain what the method is, why these three differences matter, what the evidence does and does not support, and the questions you can ask wherever you have your teeth cleaned.
First, a distinction: what are we cleaning?
Three different things build up on the tooth surface, and each needs a different tool.
| Deposit | What is it? | How is it removed? |
|---|---|---|
| Biofilm (bacterial plaque) | A soft, living layer of bacteria that sticks to the tooth. The real cause of gum disease and decay. | At home with a brush and interdental cleaning; in the clinic with air polishing |
| Tartar (calculus) | Biofilm hardened by minerals in saliva. | Ultrasonic and hand instruments |
| Stain | Discolouration left by tea, coffee, smoking and the like. | Air polishing and polishing |
The point that surprises most people is this: it is not tartar itself that causes gum disease, but the living bacterial layer on and around it. Tartar provides a rough surface for that layer to cling to.
This is why the real target of modern cleaning is biofilm. The European Federation of Periodontology guideline also defines the basis of professional care as the mechanical removal of bacterial plaque and calculus [6].
How does air polishing work?
Three things leave the tip of the device at once: pressurised air, water and a very fine powder. The mixture is directed at the tooth surface from a few millimetres away and sweeps off the soft bacterial layer.
No metal instrument touches the tooth. There is no scraping, no vibration and none of that familiar sound. The mixture also reaches places that brushes and instruments struggle with: between the teeth, crowded areas, around orthodontic wires and brackets, and crown margins.
The method has a limit, and it is important to know it: air polishing removes only the soft layer and stain. It does not remove hardened tartar [1]. So on its own it is not enough for every patient; it is one part of a protocol.
Four things that make the difference
1. The powder
This is the most important difference, and it cannot be seen from outside.
Air polishing began with sodium bicarbonate powder. The particles of traditional bicarbonate powder are coarse, up to 250 microns; it is considered highly abrasive and carries a risk for soft tissues, tooth tissues and restorations [5]. These concerns led to the development of less abrasive powders: first glycine, then erythritol-based powders [5].
| Powder | Approximate particle size | Where is it used? |
|---|---|---|
| Sodium bicarbonate (traditional) | 40 microns and above [5] | On sound enamel, above the gum line, for heavy stain |
| Glycine | 25 microns [5] | Above and below the gum line |
| Erythritol | 14 microns [5] | Above and below the gum line, on root surfaces, around restorations and implants |
In a study on composite fillings, bicarbonate powder damaged the surface more than glycine or erythritol [5].
In practice this means that the choice of powder matters for a patient with receded gums, exposed root surfaces, fillings, crowns or implants. Most adult patients fit that description.
2. The sequence
In conventional cleaning, tartar is first broken up with an ultrasonic instrument, then the teeth are polished with a rubber cup and paste. The instrument is passed over every tooth surface.
In the newer approach the order is reversed: the soft layer is first removed from the whole mouth with air polishing. Only hard tartar remains, and it is now clearly visible. The ultrasonic instrument is applied only to those spots, and only as much as needed.
The result: a metal instrument touches the tooth less, and for a shorter time.
3. Disclosing
The bacterial layer is usually tooth-coloured and invisible to the eye. Before cleaning, a harmless dye is applied to the teeth; the areas with a bacterial layer take up the colour.
The dye gives the clinician a map: cleaning follows what the dye shows instead of guesswork, and when the dye is gone the job is done. In a randomised study of thirty-two patients, less bacterial layer remained on the tooth surface after cleaning guided by a disclosing agent [4].
The dye has a second benefit: you see your own teeth in the mirror. No explanation shows as clearly which areas your brush is missing.
4. Comfort
Being able to adjust water temperature, pressure and powder flow changes the experience markedly. Warm water reduces discomfort on sensitive teeth; controlled flow and proper suction limit the spread of powder outside the mouth. Fine powders also taste different from the distinctly salty taste of traditional powder.
Side by side
| Traditional treatment | Low-abrasion treatment guided by disclosing | |
|---|---|---|
| Powder | Coarse, highly abrasive | Fine, low abrasion |
| Area of use | Sound enamel, above the gum line | Including below the gum line, root surfaces, around restorations and implants |
| Sequence | Instrument first, then polishing | Dye first, then powder, instrument if needed |
| Guidance | By eye | By what the dye shows |
| Instrument contact with the tooth | On all surfaces | Only where there is tartar |
A session step by step
- Assessment. The teeth, gums and any implants and restorations are examined. We check for anything that would rule out cleaning.
- Disclosing. Dye is applied to the teeth and the mouth is rinsed. Areas with a bacterial layer stay coloured.
- Showing. We look in the mirror together. We talk about which areas the brush is missing and give advice for home care.
- Air polishing. The stained areas are cleaned above the gum line and in the shallow gum crevice. When the dye has gone, that area is finished.
- Deeper areas. Where there are gum pockets, the inside of the pocket is cleaned with a suitable tip.
- Tartar. Remaining hard deposits are removed with an ultrasonic instrument, only from the spots where they are.
- Check. We look for any dye or tartar left behind. Fluoride is applied if needed.
- Next step. The timing of your next check-up is set according to your risk.
Disclosing is the moment most patients remember best: teeth coloured for a few minutes say more about brushing habits than words can. The colour is removed completely by the end of the session.
What does the evidence say?
A great deal is said about this method. Research actually shows three things.
Effectiveness: similar
A systematic review of thirteen clinical studies found no difference between air polishing and hand or ultrasonic instruments in controlling the bacterial layer or reducing gum inflammation [1]. The authors concluded that air polishing can be used as an alternative to these instruments during the maintenance phase of gum disease [1].
A randomised study of 50 patients, comparing a protocol that combines disclosing, low-abrasion powder and an ultrasonic instrument with the conventional method, reached the same conclusion: the two methods are equally effective [3].
Comfort: better
In a review covering nine studies, patients found cleaning with low-abrasion powder less uncomfortable than ultrasonic instruments, or at least as comfortable [2]. In the randomised study, too, patient perception favoured the new protocol [3].
Time: shorter
In the randomised study the new protocol took less time [3]. In another, twelve-month study, about a quarter of the time was saved at follow-up sessions and more patients preferred this method [7].
What we are not claiming
The evidence does not show that this method cleans teeth “better” than the conventional one. What it shows is this: a similar result is reached by a route that is more comfortable and shorter for the patient, with less intervention on tooth and restoration surfaces.
Most studies are short and long-term data are limited. Air polishing does not treat gum disease on its own, does not whiten teeth (it only removes surface stain) and does not replace care at home.
What if there is tartar?
Air polishing does not replace instruments; it reduces their workload.
Hardened tartar does not come off with powder [1]. That takes ultrasonic instruments and, where needed, hand instruments. The difference is in how much they are used: once the soft layer is gone, tartar is clearly visible and the instrument is applied only there.
Things change when gum disease is advanced. Hard deposits in deep pockets have to be removed, root surfaces smoothed, and in some cases surgery is needed. Guidelines describe the treatment of gum disease as a stepwise process and recommend regular professional care at intervals of 3 to 12 months after treatment [6].
So for a patient with heavy tartar who has not had a cleaning for a long time, the first session takes longer and instruments are used more. For patients who attend regularly, most of the session is completed with air polishing.
Who is it suitable for, and who needs care?
Those likely to benefit most
- People with implants. An implant surface must not be scratched; low-abrasion powder can be used around these surfaces.
- Orthodontic patients. Instruments struggle to reach around wires and brackets; powder does not. The same applies around attachments in clear aligner patients.
- People with crowns, veneers or composite fillings. Restoration surfaces and margins are cleaned more gently.
- People with gum recession and sensitivity. An exposed root surface is softer than enamel.
- People who dread cleaning. With less scraping and noise, the procedure is easier to tolerate.
- People with tea, coffee and tobacco stains.
Situations that need care
Tell your clinician before the procedure if any of these apply:
- Asthma, COPD or another serious respiratory condition
- A salt-restricted diet (relevant for traditional sodium bicarbonate powder)
- A known allergy to the powder or to sweeteners
- Pregnancy
- An open wound in the mouth, or a recent surgical or extraction site
- Contact lens wear (protective glasses are worn during the procedure)
Most of these do not rule out the procedure; they change the method or the powder used.
Four questions to ask where you have your teeth cleaned
You will not get the same treatment everywhere that offers air polishing. To understand the difference there is no need to ask the name of the device; these four questions are enough:
- Which powder is used? A fine, low-abrasion powder, or traditional sodium bicarbonate?
- Is disclosing done before cleaning? Is the cleaning guided by what the dye shows?
- Can it be used below the gum line and around implants and restorations? Are the powder and tip suitable for that?
- What is done about tartar? Is the instrument applied to all teeth, or only to areas with tartar?
The right answer to these questions is not the same for everyone; for someone with heavy stain on sound enamel, traditional powder may also be appropriate. What matters is that the reason a method was chosen for you can be explained.
Frequently asked questions
Does it hurt? For most patients, no. In studies, patients found cleaning with low-abrasion powder more comfortable than ultrasonic instruments, or equally comfortable [2]. Mild sensitivity may be felt where the gums are inflamed.
Does it damage enamel? Healthy enamel withstands all types of powder. The surfaces that need care are root surfaces and restorations; that is why low-abrasion powder is preferred in those areas [5].
Will it whiten my teeth? No. It removes tea, coffee and tobacco stains and returns your teeth to their own natural colour. It does not change the internal colour of the tooth; that is a separate procedure.
Does it replace scaling? Not on its own. It does not remove hard tartar [1]; where there is tartar it is used together with an ultrasonic instrument.
How often should I have it done? According to the examination findings, not the calendar. We cover this in Why a Regular Dental Check-up Is Not Only a Decay Check.
Will the dye stay on my teeth? No. The dye clings only to the bacterial layer and goes completely with the cleaning. A faint colour may remain briefly on the lips and tongue.
What should I watch out for afterwards? Cleaned surfaces are more prone to staining in the first hours. It is advisable to avoid tea, coffee, red wine and smoking for a few hours. Your clinician will tell you how long.
Can it be used in children? Yes. With no scraping sensation, children generally accept it more easily; disclosing is also an effective way to teach brushing.
I use a water flosser at home. Is it the same thing? No. A water flosser sprays only water and is for daily care; it does not replace air polishing in the clinic. For details see What Is a Water Flosser, and Does It Really Work?
Final word
Air polishing is not the name of a device but a method, and not every treatment is the same. The difference is set by the powder used, the sequence of the procedure and whether the cleaning is guided by a dye.
Done properly, it gives a result similar to conventional cleaning, more comfortably and in less time, and it touches tooth and restoration surfaces less. Even so, it is no miracle: instruments are needed for tartar, and care at home for a lasting result.
For our preventive approach, see our Periodontology / Gum Health page; for a check-up, use our appointment request form.
This article is for general information; it does not replace an examination, a diagnosis or a personal treatment plan. Which method is suitable is decided after an examination.
Taylan Akca, DDS, PhD
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon
Akca Dental Clinic
References
- Nascimento GG, Leite FRM, Pennisi PRC, López R, Paranhos LR. Use of air polishing for supra- and subgingival biofilm removal for treatment of residual periodontal pockets and supportive periodontal care: a systematic review. Clinical Oral Investigations, 2021. doi:10.1007/s00784-020-03762-y
- Bühler J, Amato M, Weiger R, Walter C. A systematic review on the patient perception of periodontal treatment using air polishing devices. International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 2016;14(1):4–14. doi:10.1111/idh.12119
- Vouros I, Antonoglou GN, Anoixiadou S, Kalfas S. A novel biofilm removal approach (Guided Biofilm Therapy) utilizing erythritol air-polishing and ultrasonic piezo instrumentation: a randomized controlled trial. International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 2022;20(2):381–390. doi:10.1111/idh.12533
- Mensi M, Scotti E, Sordillo A, Agosti R, Calza S. Plaque disclosing agent as a guide for professional biofilm removal: a randomized controlled clinical trial. International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 2020;18(3):285–294. doi:10.1111/idh.12442
- Janiszewska-Olszowska J, Drozdzik A, Tandecka K, Grocholewicz K. Effect of air-polishing on surface roughness of composite dental restorative material: comparison of three different air-polishing powders. BMC Oral Health, 2020;20:30. doi:10.1186/s12903-020-1007-y
- Sanz M, Herrera D, Kebschull M, Chapple I, Jepsen S, Berglundh T, Sculean A, Tonetti MS. Treatment of stage I–III periodontitis: the EFP S3 level clinical practice guideline. Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 2020;47(Suppl 22):4–60. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13290
- Mensi M, Scotti E, Sordillo A, Dalè M, Calza S. Air-polishing followed by ultrasonic calculus removal for the treatment of gingivitis: a 12-month, split-mouth randomized controlled clinical trial. International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 2024;22(4):949–958.