Who Is Clear Aligner Treatment Suitable For? — article image

Who Is Clear Aligner Treatment Suitable For?

Clear aligners are a good option in many cases, but not the best option in every case; the result depends as much on planning and consistent wear as on the aligners.

Short answer: yes for most people, but not for everyone

Clear aligners are no longer used only for mild crowding. Thanks to digital planning and small attachments bonded to the teeth, they can now be chosen for a much wider range of cases.

Still, the honest answer is this: clear aligners do not replace braces in every case. They do some tooth movements very well and struggle with others. And the result depends heavily on how consistently the patient wears them.

In this article we explain how aligners work, in which situations they are predictable, how they differ from braces and what they ask of you.

How do clear aligners work?

Treatment consists of a series of thin, clear aligners. Each one is made slightly different from the current position of your teeth, one step closer to the goal. When you wear an aligner it applies a light, constant force to the teeth, and the teeth take a small step towards its shape.

The process is made up of these parts:

  • Digital scanning and planning. Your teeth are recorded with an intraoral scanner and the movements are planned step by step on a computer. We describe this stage in Can Teeth Be Made Without a Conventional Impression?
  • The aligner series. Each aligner is worn for a set period, then you move on to the next. The change interval is usually one to two weeks and is set by your orthodontist.
  • Attachments. Small tooth-coloured bumps are bonded to some teeth. They let the aligner grip the tooth; without them, movements such as rotation and extrusion become difficult.
  • Interproximal reduction. To gain space, fractions of a millimetre of enamel may be removed between some teeth.
  • Elastics. If the relationship between the upper and lower jaws needs correcting, small elastics attached to the aligners may be used.

The animation you see on screen is a prediction, not a guarantee. Teeth are living tissue and do not always make the full planned movement. The next section explains that gap.

Which movements are predictable, and which are hard?

This is the most researched aspect of clear aligners: how much of the planned movement actually happens?

In a study following 38 patients, on average 50% of the planned tooth movements were achieved [3]. In the same team's earlier study the figure was 41%; so the technology has improved, but there is still a gap between plan and result [3, 8].

The gap is not the same for every movement:

Movement Predictability Note
Tipping teeth forwards or backwards Higher The most accurate movement in the study (56%) [3]
Correcting mild to moderate crowding Higher The area where aligners are strongest [1]
Closing small spaces Moderate Usually completed with additional aligners
Rotating teeth on their own axis Lower The least accurate movement (46%); even lower for canines [3]
Intruding or extruding a tooth Lower 35% for intrusion of the lower front teeth [3]
Extraction cases, marked jaw discrepancy Depends on the case Braces or combined treatment may be more suitable

A systematic review sums it up as follows: clear aligners can give acceptable results in mild and moderate cases, but most movements are not predictable enough to be completed with a single series of aligners [1].

In practice this means that when the first series ends, most patients have a mid-treatment review and additional aligners are made for the movements still needed. This is not a failure; it is a normal part of treatment.

Braces or clear aligners?

Both move teeth; they differ in where their strengths lie.

Criterion Clear aligners Fixed braces
Visibility Not noticed unless seen up close Visible (tooth-coloured options exist)
Precision of finish Can fall short of braces in adults [2] The reference method
Difficult movements Limited for rotation, intrusion and extrusion [3] More predictable
Gum health Better plaque and gum measures [4] Cleaning is harder
Pain in the first days Less; the difference disappears later [5] Slightly more
Treatment time Can be shorter in mild and moderate cases [6] Depends on the case
Reliance on the patient Very high; it does not work if not worn Low; always in the mouth
Eating and drinking Aligners are removed, no restrictions Restrictions on hard and sticky foods

The most important row in this table is the second. A meta-analysis covering 11 studies and 887 patients reported that in adults the quality of the bite achieved with clear aligners was lower than with braces [2]. The authors concluded that aligners cannot be considered equivalent to braces in every case [2].

This does not mean clear aligners are a poor option. In a well-chosen case they give very good results. It means the decision should be made not on “which is less visible” but on “which is more predictable for my teeth”.

In some cases the best route is a combination of the two: difficult movements are done with short-term braces and treatment is finished with aligners.

Half of success is in your hands

Braces work in the mouth twenty-four hours a day. A clear aligner works only while it is being worn. This is both its biggest advantage and its biggest weakness.

Aligners are generally recommended to be worn 20–22 hours a day. That means taking them out only to eat and to brush. A shortfall of a few hours a day leads, within weeks, to aligners that no longer seat on the teeth and to treatment drifting from the plan.

The daily rules are simple:

  • Take the aligners out when eating or drinking anything other than water. Hot drinks can deform them; coloured drinks stain them.
  • Brush your teeth before putting the aligners back in. Sugar trapped under the aligner stays in contact with the tooth for a long time.
  • When you take the aligners out, put them in their case. Most lost aligners are the ones wrapped in a napkin and left on a table.
  • Clean the aligners with cold water and a soft brush; do not use hot water.
  • If an aligner does not seat fully, do not move on to the next; tell your orthodontist.

Ask yourself honestly: “Can I do this every day for a year?” If the answer is no, braces may be the more reliable option for you, and there is nothing wrong with that.

How long does treatment take?

The time depends on the size of the problem to be corrected. Mild crowding can be finished in a few months; comprehensive treatment can take one to two years. The exact duration can only be given after an examination and planning.

Three factors affect the duration:

  • The aligner change interval. In a randomised trial, the group that changed aligners every 7 days finished in roughly half the time of the group that changed every 14 days (5 months versus 9 months) [8]. The same trial notes that a 14-day interval may be more suitable for difficult movements of the back teeth [8]. So your orthodontist chooses the interval for your case.
  • The need for additional aligners. The first series is often not the whole treatment. Additional aligners for the movements still needed lengthen the total time [1].
  • Wear habits. Aligners not worn enough are the most common cause of delay.

The evidence on duration is mixed. A meta-analysis reported that in mild and moderate cases treatment time and chair time were shorter with clear aligners [6]. In difficult cases, additional aligners can make treatment longer than with braces.

Ask at the outset whether the time you are given is for the “first series” or for the “whole treatment”.

Limits and risks

Clear aligner treatment is orthodontic treatment, and the risks of any orthodontic treatment apply to it too.

  • Not fully reaching the goal. Part of the planned movement may not happen; additional aligners or short-term braces may be needed.
  • Decay and gum problems. The aligner partly separates the teeth from the protective effect of saliva. An aligner put in without brushing increases the risk of decay.
  • Root shortening. A small amount can occur in any treatment that moves teeth; it is usually of no clinical importance.
  • Gum recession. It can occur where the bone is thin if teeth are moved beyond the bone boundary. That is why planning takes the condition of the gum and bone into account.
  • Relapse. Without retention after treatment, teeth tend to drift back to their old positions.

In some situations another problem needs to be dealt with before treatment begins. Active gum disease must be treated first. Untreated decay must be filled. If you clench your teeth, tell your orthodontist; it can affect the life of the aligners and the planning.

Aligner systems sent out on the basis of an impression taken at home, without an examination by a clinician, include none of these checks. Moving teeth is a medical procedure and should not be started without an in-person examination and an X-ray assessment.

After treatment: retention

The last aligner is not the end of treatment. Until the teeth settle into their new positions, and even afterwards, they tend to drift back.

The Cochrane review states this clearly: without a period of retention after orthodontic treatment, teeth move back towards their starting positions [7]. This applies to braces and aligners alike.

Retention is done in two ways, and the two are often combined:

  • Fixed retainer. A thin wire bonded to the back of the front teeth. It is invisible and cannot be removed; it needs careful cleaning.
  • Removable retainer. A clear aligner-like retainer worn at night. It wears over time and needs replacing.

The evidence on which retainer is better is not strong enough [7]. The one clear point is that retention is a long-term commitment. When you start treatment, think of it as part of the plan.

Frequently asked questions

Do clear aligners hurt? Pressure and tenderness in the first day or two of each new aligner are normal. According to a systematic review, people with clear aligners report less pain in the first days than those with braces; the difference disappears later [5].

Will they affect my speech? There may be a slight lisp in the first days. For most people the tongue gets used to the aligner within a few days.

Are the attachments visible? They are tooth-coloured and not noticeable from a distance, but they can be seen up close. This is the most common surprise for patients who think aligners are completely invisible.

Is there an age limit? There is no upper age limit for adults; what decides is the health of the gums and bone. They can also be used in teenagers, but whether they can take on the responsibility of consistent wear should be assessed honestly.

I have crowns, a bridge or implants. Can I have clear aligners? Usually yes. Crowned teeth can be moved, but bonding attachments to them is harder. Implants do not move; the plan is made on the assumption that they stay fixed.

Wouldn't it be quicker to straighten my teeth with veneers or crowns? It is quicker, but irreversible. If the real problem with healthy teeth is their alignment, orthodontic options should be considered first. We discuss this in Good Treatment Thinks About the Years Ahead, Too.

Can teeth be whitened with the aligners? It is possible in some cases, but a colour difference can appear around attachments. Do not do it without asking your orthodontist.

What happens if I lose an aligner? Call your orthodontist. Depending on the situation you may be asked to go back to the previous aligner or move on to the next. Do not skip ahead on your own.

How often will I have check-ups during treatment? Usually every few weeks. At check-ups the fit of the aligners, the attachments and gum health are assessed.

Final word

A clear aligner is a good tool, but it is a tool. What decides the result is not the aligner itself, but the right diagnosis, a realistic plan and your consistent wear.

Whether it suits you is determined by an orthodontic examination, X-rays and digital records. At the examination we suggest asking three questions: Which movements are difficult in my case? How likely am I to need additional aligners? Would the result be different with braces?

For details of the treatment options, see our Clear Aligner Treatment and Orthodontics pages.

This article is for general information; it does not replace an examination or a personal treatment plan. Treatment results can vary from person to person.

Çağrı Dinçyürek
Orthodontist
Akca Dental Clinic

References

  1. Robertson L, Kaur H, Fagundes NCF, Romanyk D, Major P, Flores-Mir C. Effectiveness of clear aligner therapy for orthodontic treatment: a systematic review. Orthodontics & Craniofacial Research, 2020;23(2):133–142. doi:10.1111/ocr.12353
  2. Papageorgiou SN, Koletsi D, Iliadi A, Peltomaki T, Eliades T. Treatment outcome with orthodontic aligners and fixed appliances: a systematic review with meta-analyses. European Journal of Orthodontics, 2020;42(3):331–343. doi:10.1093/ejo/cjz094
  3. Haouili N, Kravitz ND, Vaid NR, Ferguson DJ, Makki L. Has Invisalign improved? A prospective follow-up study on the efficacy of tooth movement with Invisalign. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2020;158(3):420–425. doi:10.1016/j.ajodo.2019.12.015
  4. Jiang Q, Li J, Mei L, Du J, Levrini L, Abbate GM, Li H. Periodontal health during orthodontic treatment with clear aligners and fixed appliances: a meta-analysis. Journal of the American Dental Association, 2018;149(8):712–720. doi:10.1016/j.adaj.2018.04.010
  5. Cardoso PC, Espinosa DG, Mecenas P, Flores-Mir C, Normando D. Pain level between clear aligners and fixed appliances: a systematic review. Progress in Orthodontics, 2020;21:3. doi:10.1186/s40510-019-0303-z
  6. Zheng M, Liu R, Ni Z, Yu Z. Efficiency, effectiveness and treatment stability of clear aligners: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Orthodontics & Craniofacial Research, 2017;20(3):127–133. doi:10.1111/ocr.12177
  7. Martin C, Littlewood SJ, Millett DT, Doubleday B, Bearn D, Worthington HV, Limones A. Retention procedures for stabilising tooth position after treatment with orthodontic braces. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2023. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD002283.pub5
  8. Al-Nadawi M, Kravitz ND, Hansa I, Makki L, Ferguson DJ, Vaid NR. Effect of clear aligner wear protocol on the efficacy of tooth movement: a randomized clinical trial. The Angle Orthodontist, 2021;91(2):157–163. doi:10.2319/071520-630.1