Can Teeth Be Made Without a Conventional Impression? — article image

Can Teeth Be Made Without a Conventional Impression?

In most treatments an intraoral scan can replace impression putty; for single teeth and short bridges its accuracy is on a par with conventional impressions.

Short answer: in most treatments, yes

A tray full of putty in your mouth, minutes of waiting, the urge to gag. Anyone who has had a dental impression remembers that moment, and most would rather not repeat it.

Today many treatments no longer need it. A pen-sized camera is moved over the teeth to build a three-dimensional digital model of the mouth. Crowns, bridges, implant teeth, clear aligners and night guards can all be made from this model.

Even so, “always” would be the wrong word. There are situations where digital scanning does very well and situations where a conventional impression is still preferred. This article covers both.

What is a conventional impression, and why is it unpleasant?

In a conventional impression, a soft material is placed in a metal or plastic tray, pressed over the teeth and left to set. Plaster is poured into the mould to produce a model of the teeth. The method has been used for decades and is very precise when done well.

The problem is not its precision but the experience:

  • The material fills the mouth, and you have to stay still for a few minutes until it sets.
  • It can be a hard moment for people with a sensitive gag reflex.
  • The taste and smell of the material are not pleasant.
  • If the impression has an air bubble or a tear, the whole thing is taken again.

There is also a part you do not see. Impression material can change size over time, plaster expands as it sets, and the model can be damaged on its way to the laboratory. Each step adds a small margin of error [1].

How does digital scanning work?

An intraoral scanner is a pen-like device with a small camera at its tip. The clinician moves this tip slowly over the teeth.

The device captures thousands of images per second and stitches them together instantly into a three-dimensional model of your teeth on the screen. You can watch the model take shape.

A few things worth knowing:

  • There is no radiation. A scan is not an X-ray; it is imaging with light.
  • You can take a break. If you get tired or need to swallow, the scan is paused and picks up where it left off.
  • Missing areas are rescanned. If one area is unclear, only that area is repeated; there is no need to start again.
  • The bite is recorded too. After the upper and lower jaws are scanned separately, a short scan is taken from the side with the teeth together.
  • Colour is captured. Most scanners also record the colour of the teeth and gums.

Scanning the whole mouth usually takes a few minutes.

The difference for the patient

Comfort

One of the first clinical studies on this question was carried out in Istanbul. Twenty-four volunteers who had experienced neither method had a conventional impression first and a digital one two weeks later [1]. Participants found the digital impression more comfortable and preferred it to the conventional method [1].

Later studies point the same way. A systematic review of five clinical studies concluded that patients prefer digital impressions [2]. A more recent review also reports that intraoral scanning improves patient comfort and is generally preferred [3].

Time

Here the picture is less clear than for comfort. In the Istanbul study the digital method took less time [1]. In the 2018 review, three studies found digital faster and two found conventional faster, and the authors concluded that the times were similar [2]. The balance has shifted as scanners have improved: the 2021 review reports that scanning shortens procedure time [3].

So the honest summary is this: digital scanning is clearly more comfortable; whether it is faster depends on the device, the area scanned and the clinician's experience.

Other differences

  • Seeing is understanding. You see your teeth enlarged on the screen from every angle. Wear, cracks or gum recession are shown rather than described.
  • No retakes later. No mould comes back from the laboratory marked “faulty impression”; if there is a problem, it is spotted while you are still in the chair.
  • The record stays. The scan is stored digitally and can be compared with a new scan years later.

But is it accurate?

Comfort is welcome, but the real question is this: does a tooth made from a scan fit as well as one made from a putty impression?

The answer depends on the type of treatment.

Treatment Accuracy of digital scanning Note
Single crown, short bridge, inlay and veneer On a par with conventional impressions [5] Marginal fit similar or better [4]
Single implant tooth and short implant bridge Clinically acceptable [5] In widespread use
Clear aligners, night guards, study models Suitable Has become the standard method in these areas
Full-arch fixed prosthesis on implants Developing; case by case [5, 6] Explained below
Removable denture in a fully edentulous jaw Limited [7] Struggles with movable tissue

Where it does well

In a meta-analysis of fixed restorations, the marginal fit of crowns made from digital impressions was similar to that of crowns made from conventional ones [4]. The authors concluded that the digital technique gave better fit, but also noted that the findings rest mostly on laboratory studies [4].

Another systematic review sums it up as follows: for crowns and short bridges, the accuracy of digital impressions is at the same level as conventional methods; for implant crowns and bridges it is clinically acceptable [5].

Where it is limited: the full arch

A scanner works by adding images side by side. Over a longer distance, small errors can add up. A difference that is trivial for a single tooth matters for a prosthesis that runs from one end of the jaw to the other and has to seat on several implants at once.

The 2018 review reported that conventional impressions were more accurate for full-arch cases and still recommended them there [5]. A more recent review found that current scanners reach acceptable accuracy under laboratory conditions and, in direct comparisons, are at least equivalent to the conventional method [6]. The same review lists the factors that affect the result: the distance between implants, the design of the scan body, the scanning sequence and the clinician's experience [6].

This field is changing fast. The accurate statement today is this: digital scanning can be used for full-arch implant prostheses, but depending on the case it may need to be backed up by a conventional impression or additional verification methods.

What happens after the scan?

The scan is only the first step. Once the digital model exists, the process runs as follows:

  1. Check. The clinician reviews the model on screen, checking that the margins are clear and the bite is recorded correctly.
  2. Sending. The file is sent to the laboratory digitally. There is no risk of distortion in transit.
  3. Design. The tooth is designed on a computer. Shape, contact with neighbouring teeth and the bite against the opposing tooth are adjusted on screen.
  4. Production. The design is milled from a block or made on a 3D printer; where needed, a technician finishes the shape and colour by hand.
  5. Try-in and fitting. The tooth is tried in the mouth, fine adjustments are made and it is fixed in place.

The value of a scan beyond the impression

The digital model is kept. This makes possible something that is hard in practice with plaster models: measuring change over time.

  • Scans taken two years apart can be overlaid to see whether tooth wear is progressing. We cover this in Why Does Tooth Wear Occur?
  • Gum recession and tooth movement can be monitored.
  • A broken temporary tooth or a lost night guard can be remade from the stored record.
  • In treatment planning, the scan can be combined with a CT scan to decide the implant position in advance.

In clear aligner treatment, the scan is where it all begins; for details see Who Is Clear Aligner Treatment Suitable For?

When digital scanning is not enough

A scanner is a camera: it records what it sees and cannot record what it cannot see. Most of its limits follow from that.

  • Margins below the gum line. If the edge of a tooth prepared for a crown lies deep under the gum, the camera cannot see it. Conventional impression material can flow into that area.
  • Bleeding and saliva. A wet, bleeding surface does not scan clearly. If gum health is poor, it needs to improve first.
  • Fully edentulous jaws. A jaw with no teeth offers few distinct landmarks for the camera. According to a systematic review, scanners record firm, fixed tissue with accuracy close to conventional impressions; deviations increase in movable tissue, in the areas where denture borders sit and in the soft palate [7].
  • The suction of removable dentures. The retention of a full denture depends on the shape of the tissues during function; recording that usually requires the conventional method.
  • Long-span implant prostheses. As explained above, additional verification may be needed depending on the case.
  • Patients with limited mouth opening. It can be hard for the camera to reach the back areas.

Taking a conventional impression in these situations is not clinging to the old way; it is choosing the right tool. A good clinic uses both and can explain why one was chosen.

Who benefits most?

  • People with a sensitive gag reflex. This is the group that struggles most with conventional impressions; with no material filling the mouth, a scan is far easier to tolerate.
  • People with dental anxiety. The procedure can be paused on request; the patient is in control.
  • Children and teenagers. A putty impression for orthodontic records is hard for most children.
  • Anyone having clear aligners or a night guard. These appliances are made directly from the digital model.
  • Implant patients. Scanning can be used at the planning, temporary tooth and final tooth stages. We describe the process in Can a Tooth Be Fitted on the Day an Implant Is Placed?
  • Patients travelling from abroad or short of time. The file reaches the laboratory instantly; there is no wait for a courier, and the risk of an extra visit to retake an impression is lower.
  • Patients being monitored for wear or gum recession. Regular scans make change measurable.

Frequently asked questions

Will I be exposed to radiation during the scan? No. An intraoral scan uses light; it is not an X-ray or a CT scan. It can also be done during pregnancy.

Does it hurt? No. The camera tip touches the teeth and cheek lightly. Apart from a little stretching of the cheek while the back teeth are scanned, no discomfort is expected.

How long does it take? Scanning the whole mouth usually takes a few minutes. A single tooth or area takes less.

My gag reflex is very sensitive. Can I be scanned? Usually yes. Nothing fills the mouth, and a break is taken when needed. There may be brief sensitivity while the very back teeth are scanned.

Will a tooth made from a scan fit as well as one made from a conventional impression? For single crowns and short bridges, yes; accuracy is at the same level [5] and marginal fit is similar or better [4].

My dentist still took a putty impression after the scan. Why? Most likely there is a situation where scanning falls short: a margin below the gum line, an edentulous area or a long implant prosthesis. It is a choice made to get the right result.

Where is my scan data stored? Digital records are part of your patient file and are protected as personal health data. You can read the clinic's privacy notice for details and ask how long records are kept.

Can I take my scan to another dentist? Yes. Scan files can be exported in common file formats. You only need to ask.

Does a digital impression change the cost of treatment? It varies by clinic. You can ask at the treatment-planning stage which method will be used and whether it affects the fee.

Final word

Digital scanning has largely removed one of the moments patients complain about most in dentistry. For single teeth and short bridges its accuracy is on a par with conventional impressions, and it is clearly more comfortable for the patient.

It has not replaced everything. For margins below the gum line, edentulous jaws and full-arch implant prostheses, the conventional impression still holds its place or complements the scan. What matters is not the name of the method but which one will give the more accurate result for your treatment.

For more on the digital workflow, see our Digital Dentistry page.

This article is for general information; it does not replace an examination or a personal treatment plan. Which impression method is suitable depends on the type of treatment.

Taylan Akca, DDS, PhD
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon
Akca Dental Clinic

References

  1. Yüzbaşıoğlu E, Kurt H, Turunç R, Bilir H. Comparison of digital and conventional impression techniques: evaluation of patients' perception, treatment comfort, effectiveness and clinical outcomes. BMC Oral Health, 2014;14:10. doi:10.1186/1472-6831-14-10
  2. Gallardo YR, Bohner L, Tortamano P, Pigozzo MN, Laganá DC, Sesma N. Patient outcomes and procedure working time for digital versus conventional impressions: a systematic review. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2018;119(2):214–219.
  3. Siqueira R, et al. Intraoral scanning reduces procedure time and improves patient comfort in fixed prosthodontics and implant dentistry: a systematic review. Clinical Oral Investigations, 2021. doi:10.1007/s00784-021-04157-3
  4. Chochlidakis KM, Papaspyridakos P, Geminiani A, Chen CJ, Feng IJ, Ercoli C. Digital versus conventional impressions for fixed prosthodontics: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2016;116(2):184–190. doi:10.1016/j.prosdent.2015.12.017
  5. Ahlholm P, Sipilä K, Vallittu P, Jakonen M, Kotiranta U. Digital versus conventional impressions in fixed prosthodontics: a review. Journal of Prosthodontics, 2018;27(1):35–41. doi:10.1111/jopr.12527
  6. Wulfman C, Naveau A, Rignon-Bret C. Digital scanning for complete-arch implant-supported restorations: a systematic review. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2020;124(2):161–167. doi:10.1016/j.prosdent.2019.06.014
  7. Srivastava G, Padhiary SK, Mohanty N, Molinero-Mourelle P, Chebib N. Accuracy of intraoral scanner for recording completely edentulous arches: a systematic review. Dentistry Journal, 2023;11(10):241. doi:10.3390/dj11100241